Model run by trashe using Apollo 0.4.0 on R 4.5.3 for Linux. Please acknowledge the use of Apollo by citing Hess & Palma (2019) DOI 10.1016/j.jocm.2019.100170 www.ApolloChoiceModelling.com Model name : LC_MMNL Model description : Latent class with continuous random parameters on Swiss route choice data Model run at : 2026-11-02 21:59:06 Estimation method : bgw Estimation diagnosis : Relative function convergence (favorable) Optimisation diagnosis : Maximum found hessian properties : Negative definite maximum eigenvalue : -6.107961 reciprocal of condition number : 5.28191e-05 Number of individuals : 388 Number of rows in database : 3492 Number of modelled outcomes : 3492 Number of cores used : 4 Number of inter-individual draws : 500 (halton) LL(start) : -2370.05 LL (whole model) at equal shares, LL(0) : -2420.47 LL (whole model) at observed shares, LL(C) : -2420.39 LL(final, whole model) : -1497.87 Rho-squared vs equal shares : 0.3812 Adj.Rho-squared vs equal shares : 0.3754 Rho-squared vs observed shares : 0.3811 Adj.Rho-squared vs observed shares : 0.3758 AIC : 3023.74 BIC : 3109.96 LL(0,Class_1) : -2420.47 LL(final,Class_1) : -1704.92 LL(0,Class_2) : -2420.47 LL(final,Class_2) : -2028.16 Estimated parameters : 14 Time taken (hh:mm:ss) : 00:00:56.31 pre-estimation : 00:00:6.23 estimation : 00:00:19.41 post-estimation : 00:00:30.67 Iterations : 25 Unconstrained optimisation. Estimates: Estimate s.e. t.rat.(0) Rob.s.e. Rob.t.rat.(0) asc1 -0.03015 0.052845 -0.5705 0.058601 -0.5145 asc2 0.00000 NA NA NA NA log_tt_a_mu -3.13439 0.207627 -15.0963 0.249298 -12.5729 log_tt_b_mu -1.59919 0.157053 -10.1825 0.231674 -6.9028 log_tt_a_sig 0.74595 0.145392 5.1306 0.139433 5.3499 log_tt_b_sig 0.57190 0.090383 6.3275 0.109002 5.2467 tc_a -0.08389 0.019637 -4.2718 0.017864 -4.6959 tc_b -0.81829 0.141382 -5.7878 0.317745 -2.5753 hw_a -0.04267 0.004030 -10.5888 0.008255 -5.1691 hw_b -0.05601 0.005594 -10.0118 0.008377 -6.6863 ch_a -0.70310 0.112427 -6.2539 0.231054 -3.0430 ch_b -2.94513 0.302290 -9.7427 0.347463 -8.4761 delta_a -0.34005 0.272101 -1.2497 0.396539 -0.8575 gamma_commute_a -0.11024 0.344940 -0.3196 0.396214 -0.2782 gamma_car_av_a 0.49175 0.293570 1.6751 0.330205 1.4892 delta_b 0.00000 NA NA NA NA gamma_commute_b 0.00000 NA NA NA NA gamma_car_av_b 0.00000 NA NA NA NA Summary of class allocation for model component : Mean prob. Class_1 0.4544 Class_2 0.5456 Overview of choices for MNL model component Class_1: alt1 alt2 Times available 3492.00 3492.00 Times chosen 1734.00 1758.00 Percentage chosen overall 49.66 50.34 Percentage chosen when available 49.66 50.34 Overview of choices for MNL model component Class_2: alt1 alt2 Times available 3492.00 3492.00 Times chosen 1734.00 1758.00 Percentage chosen overall 49.66 50.34 Percentage chosen when available 49.66 50.34 Classical covariance matrix: asc1 log_tt_a_mu log_tt_b_mu log_tt_a_sig asc1 0.002793 7.507e-05 -5.681e-05 2.241e-05 log_tt_a_mu 7.507e-05 0.043109 1.0474e-04 -0.014641 log_tt_b_mu -5.681e-05 1.0474e-04 0.024666 0.002446 log_tt_a_sig 2.241e-05 -0.014641 0.002446 0.021139 log_tt_b_sig 4.173e-05 -8.6913e-04 -0.005002 -0.004617 tc_a -2.054e-05 -0.002799 -4.4935e-04 6.8999e-04 tc_b -1.044e-05 -0.005888 -0.018260 -6.3643e-04 hw_a -7.774e-07 -2.8933e-04 -1.0947e-04 9.300e-06 hw_b 2.866e-06 2.0128e-04 -1.7996e-04 -1.502e-05 ch_a -4.717e-06 -0.008018 -0.008343 -3.4109e-04 ch_b 4.8437e-04 -0.002346 -0.031435 -0.002751 delta_a -1.2433e-04 0.011376 0.020631 0.002348 gamma_commute_a -7.748e-05 0.003060 0.002806 -0.001397 gamma_car_av_a 1.770e-06 0.005615 -0.002679 -1.8213e-04 log_tt_b_sig tc_a tc_b hw_a asc1 4.173e-05 -2.054e-05 -1.044e-05 -7.774e-07 log_tt_a_mu -8.6913e-04 -0.002799 -0.005888 -2.8933e-04 log_tt_b_mu -0.005002 -4.4935e-04 -0.018260 -1.0947e-04 log_tt_a_sig -0.004617 6.8999e-04 -6.3643e-04 9.300e-06 log_tt_b_sig 0.008169 1.1779e-04 0.002850 1.374e-05 tc_a 1.1779e-04 3.8562e-04 5.8676e-04 2.239e-05 tc_b 0.002850 5.8676e-04 0.019989 1.9700e-04 hw_a 1.374e-05 2.239e-05 1.9700e-04 1.624e-05 hw_b -4.341e-05 -9.375e-06 9.356e-05 -8.392e-06 ch_a 0.001326 7.6063e-04 0.010112 2.5706e-04 ch_b 0.002619 0.001265 0.024009 9.842e-05 delta_a -0.004441 -0.001479 -0.022005 -3.0204e-04 gamma_commute_a 0.001636 -4.5133e-04 -4.2219e-04 -1.8896e-04 gamma_car_av_a -0.001423 -1.2148e-04 -3.2388e-04 -1.1499e-04 hw_b ch_a ch_b delta_a asc1 2.866e-06 -4.717e-06 4.8437e-04 -1.2433e-04 log_tt_a_mu 2.0128e-04 -0.008018 -0.002346 0.011376 log_tt_b_mu -1.7996e-04 -0.008343 -0.031435 0.020631 log_tt_a_sig -1.502e-05 -3.4109e-04 -0.002751 0.002348 log_tt_b_sig -4.341e-05 0.001326 0.002619 -0.004441 tc_a -9.375e-06 7.6063e-04 0.001265 -0.001479 tc_b 9.356e-05 0.010112 0.024009 -0.022005 hw_a -8.392e-06 2.5706e-04 9.842e-05 -3.0204e-04 hw_b 3.130e-05 -1.2483e-04 5.0546e-04 1.920e-05 ch_a -1.2483e-04 0.012640 0.013566 -0.018549 ch_b 5.0546e-04 0.013566 0.091379 -0.039849 delta_a 1.920e-05 -0.018549 -0.039849 0.074039 gamma_commute_a 1.8648e-04 -0.004910 -0.022157 -0.016505 gamma_car_av_a 2.3238e-04 -0.001451 0.010788 -0.032490 gamma_commute_a gamma_car_av_a asc1 -7.748e-05 1.770e-06 log_tt_a_mu 0.003060 0.005615 log_tt_b_mu 0.002806 -0.002679 log_tt_a_sig -0.001397 -1.8213e-04 log_tt_b_sig 0.001636 -0.001423 tc_a -4.5133e-04 -1.2148e-04 tc_b -4.2219e-04 -3.2388e-04 hw_a -1.8896e-04 -1.1499e-04 hw_b 1.8648e-04 2.3238e-04 ch_a -0.004910 -0.001451 ch_b -0.022157 0.010788 delta_a -0.016505 -0.032490 gamma_commute_a 0.118984 -0.005939 gamma_car_av_a -0.005939 0.086184 Robust covariance matrix: asc1 log_tt_a_mu log_tt_b_mu log_tt_a_sig asc1 0.003434 0.001972 6.1611e-04 -1.7465e-04 log_tt_a_mu 0.001972 0.062149 0.024361 -0.012727 log_tt_b_mu 6.1611e-04 0.024361 0.053673 -2.1497e-04 log_tt_a_sig -1.7465e-04 -0.012727 -2.1497e-04 0.019441 log_tt_b_sig -3.803e-05 -0.002489 -0.008642 -0.006345 tc_a -1.4876e-04 -0.003159 -0.001461 5.3861e-04 tc_b -0.001659 -0.049905 -0.064888 0.005644 hw_a -7.333e-05 -0.001454 -0.001056 1.2854e-04 hw_b 5.082e-05 0.001166 5.7825e-04 -9.994e-05 ch_a -0.001391 -0.038057 -0.040305 0.002691 ch_b 0.002280 0.002833 -0.038055 -0.005016 delta_a 0.001600 0.046898 0.070622 -0.001877 gamma_commute_a 7.9616e-04 0.005653 -0.006624 -0.003126 gamma_car_av_a -7.1059e-04 0.034719 0.012214 -1.2156e-04 log_tt_b_sig tc_a tc_b hw_a asc1 -3.803e-05 -1.4876e-04 -0.001659 -7.333e-05 log_tt_a_mu -0.002489 -0.003159 -0.049905 -0.001454 log_tt_b_mu -0.008642 -0.001461 -0.064888 -0.001056 log_tt_a_sig -0.006345 5.3861e-04 0.005644 1.2854e-04 log_tt_b_sig 0.011881 1.7588e-04 0.005783 6.886e-05 tc_a 1.7588e-04 3.1912e-04 0.002425 7.864e-05 tc_b 0.005783 0.002425 0.100962 0.001868 hw_a 6.886e-05 7.864e-05 0.001868 6.815e-05 hw_b -1.1084e-04 -6.560e-05 -0.001210 -4.748e-05 ch_a 0.003522 0.001995 0.063395 0.001591 ch_b 0.004844 9.2202e-04 0.022181 3.1765e-04 delta_a -0.008112 -0.002610 -0.100836 -0.001947 gamma_commute_a 0.005058 -0.001298 0.016251 -5.8094e-04 gamma_car_av_a -0.006121 -0.001580 -0.031805 -0.001126 hw_b ch_a ch_b delta_a asc1 5.082e-05 -0.001391 0.002280 0.001600 log_tt_a_mu 0.001166 -0.038057 0.002833 0.046898 log_tt_b_mu 5.7825e-04 -0.040305 -0.038055 0.070622 log_tt_a_sig -9.994e-05 0.002691 -0.005016 -0.001877 log_tt_b_sig -1.1084e-04 0.003522 0.004844 -0.008112 tc_a -6.560e-05 0.001995 9.2202e-04 -0.002610 tc_b -0.001210 0.063395 0.022181 -0.100836 hw_a -4.748e-05 0.001591 3.1765e-04 -0.001947 hw_b 7.017e-05 -0.001179 3.131e-05 0.001362 ch_a -0.001179 0.053386 0.022461 -0.075483 ch_b 3.131e-05 0.022461 0.120731 -0.055284 delta_a 0.001362 -0.075483 -0.055284 0.157243 gamma_commute_a 7.6419e-04 -0.006094 -0.046242 -0.020675 gamma_car_av_a 0.001112 -0.023786 0.023796 -0.004564 gamma_commute_a gamma_car_av_a asc1 7.9616e-04 -7.1059e-04 log_tt_a_mu 0.005653 0.034719 log_tt_b_mu -0.006624 0.012214 log_tt_a_sig -0.003126 -1.2156e-04 log_tt_b_sig 0.005058 -0.006121 tc_a -0.001298 -0.001580 tc_b 0.016251 -0.031805 hw_a -5.8094e-04 -0.001126 hw_b 7.6419e-04 0.001112 ch_a -0.006094 -0.023786 ch_b -0.046242 0.023796 delta_a -0.020675 -0.004564 gamma_commute_a 0.156985 -0.009704 gamma_car_av_a -0.009704 0.109036 Classical correlation matrix: asc1 log_tt_a_mu log_tt_b_mu log_tt_a_sig asc1 1.000000 0.006842 -0.006845 0.002917 log_tt_a_mu 0.006842 1.000000 0.003212 -0.485011 log_tt_b_mu -0.006845 0.003212 1.000000 0.107102 log_tt_a_sig 0.002917 -0.485011 0.107102 1.000000 log_tt_b_sig 0.008736 -0.046314 -0.352346 -0.351371 tc_a -0.019795 -0.686615 -0.145700 0.241670 tc_b -0.001397 -0.200586 -0.822351 -0.030961 hw_a -0.003650 -0.345792 -0.172963 0.015873 hw_b 0.009694 0.173283 -0.204824 -0.018470 ch_a -7.9400e-04 -0.343482 -0.472509 -0.020867 ch_b 0.030322 -0.037371 -0.662121 -0.062602 delta_a -0.008646 0.201368 0.482766 0.059362 gamma_commute_a -0.004250 0.042726 0.051792 -0.027855 gamma_car_av_a 1.1411e-04 0.092113 -0.058107 -0.004267 log_tt_b_sig tc_a tc_b hw_a asc1 0.008736 -0.01980 -0.001397 -0.003650 log_tt_a_mu -0.046314 -0.68661 -0.200586 -0.345792 log_tt_b_mu -0.352346 -0.14570 -0.822351 -0.172963 log_tt_a_sig -0.351371 0.24167 -0.030961 0.015873 log_tt_b_sig 1.000000 0.06636 0.223064 0.037736 tc_a 0.066363 1.00000 0.211342 0.282874 tc_b 0.223064 0.21134 1.000000 0.345763 hw_a 0.037736 0.28287 0.345763 1.000000 hw_b -0.085860 -0.08534 0.118284 -0.372215 ch_a 0.130459 0.34453 0.636180 0.567389 ch_b 0.095852 0.21318 0.561759 0.080791 delta_a -0.180585 -0.27686 -0.572001 -0.275451 gamma_commute_a 0.052487 -0.06663 -0.008657 -0.135934 gamma_car_av_a -0.053640 -0.02107 -0.007803 -0.097200 hw_b ch_a ch_b delta_a asc1 0.009694 -7.9400e-04 0.03032 -0.008646 log_tt_a_mu 0.173283 -0.34348 -0.03737 0.201368 log_tt_b_mu -0.204824 -0.47251 -0.66212 0.482766 log_tt_a_sig -0.018470 -0.02087 -0.06260 0.059362 log_tt_b_sig -0.085860 0.13046 0.09585 -0.180585 tc_a -0.085337 0.34453 0.21318 -0.276862 tc_b 0.118284 0.63618 0.56176 -0.572001 hw_a -0.372215 0.56739 0.08079 -0.275451 hw_b 1.000000 -0.19847 0.29889 0.012611 ch_a -0.198473 1.00000 0.39918 -0.606346 ch_b 0.298885 0.39918 1.00000 -0.484464 delta_a 0.012611 -0.60635 -0.48446 1.000000 gamma_commute_a 0.096632 -0.12660 -0.21249 -0.175852 gamma_car_av_a 0.141491 -0.04397 0.12157 -0.406729 gamma_commute_a gamma_car_av_a asc1 -0.004250 1.1411e-04 log_tt_a_mu 0.042726 0.092113 log_tt_b_mu 0.051792 -0.058107 log_tt_a_sig -0.027855 -0.004267 log_tt_b_sig 0.052487 -0.053640 tc_a -0.066629 -0.021072 tc_b -0.008657 -0.007803 hw_a -0.135934 -0.097200 hw_b 0.096632 0.141491 ch_a -0.126600 -0.043973 ch_b -0.212488 0.121568 delta_a -0.175852 -0.406729 gamma_commute_a 1.000000 -0.058652 gamma_car_av_a -0.058652 1.000000 Robust correlation matrix: asc1 log_tt_a_mu log_tt_b_mu log_tt_a_sig asc1 1.000000 0.13497 0.045381 -0.021374 log_tt_a_mu 0.134967 1.00000 0.421790 -0.366143 log_tt_b_mu 0.045381 0.42179 1.000000 -0.006655 log_tt_a_sig -0.021374 -0.36614 -0.006655 1.000000 log_tt_b_sig -0.005953 -0.09159 -0.342232 -0.417458 tc_a -0.142100 -0.70939 -0.353001 0.216238 tc_b -0.089085 -0.63001 -0.881477 0.127398 hw_a -0.151592 -0.70645 -0.551925 0.111676 hw_b 0.103523 0.55824 0.297959 -0.085566 ch_a -0.102753 -0.66069 -0.752953 0.083538 ch_b 0.111958 0.03270 -0.472739 -0.103539 delta_a 0.068847 0.47440 0.768739 -0.033951 gamma_commute_a 0.034290 0.05724 -0.072161 -0.056576 gamma_car_av_a -0.036722 0.42176 0.159664 -0.002640 log_tt_b_sig tc_a tc_b hw_a asc1 -0.005953 -0.14210 -0.08909 -0.15159 log_tt_a_mu -0.091594 -0.70939 -0.63001 -0.70645 log_tt_b_mu -0.342232 -0.35300 -0.88148 -0.55193 log_tt_a_sig -0.417458 0.21624 0.12740 0.11168 log_tt_b_sig 1.000000 0.09032 0.16698 0.07652 tc_a 0.090323 1.00000 0.42728 0.53322 tc_b 0.166979 0.42728 1.00000 0.71202 hw_a 0.076522 0.53322 0.71202 1.00000 hw_b -0.121387 -0.43838 -0.45472 -0.68665 ch_a 0.139848 0.48341 0.86350 0.83422 ch_b 0.127887 0.14854 0.20090 0.11074 delta_a -0.187669 -0.36850 -0.80030 -0.59484 gamma_commute_a 0.117126 -0.18343 0.12909 -0.17761 gamma_car_av_a -0.170071 -0.26789 -0.30313 -0.41310 hw_b ch_a ch_b delta_a asc1 0.10352 -0.10275 0.11196 0.06885 log_tt_a_mu 0.55824 -0.66069 0.03270 0.47440 log_tt_b_mu 0.29796 -0.75295 -0.47274 0.76874 log_tt_a_sig -0.08557 0.08354 -0.10354 -0.03395 log_tt_b_sig -0.12139 0.13985 0.12789 -0.18767 tc_a -0.43838 0.48341 0.14854 -0.36850 tc_b -0.45472 0.86350 0.20090 -0.80030 hw_a -0.68665 0.83422 0.11074 -0.59484 hw_b 1.00000 -0.60917 0.01076 0.41008 ch_a -0.60917 1.00000 0.27977 -0.82386 ch_b 0.01076 0.27977 1.00000 -0.40124 delta_a 0.41008 -0.82386 -0.40124 1.00000 gamma_commute_a 0.23024 -0.06656 -0.33589 -0.13160 gamma_car_av_a 0.40183 -0.31176 0.20741 -0.03486 gamma_commute_a gamma_car_av_a asc1 0.03429 -0.036722 log_tt_a_mu 0.05724 0.421761 log_tt_b_mu -0.07216 0.159664 log_tt_a_sig -0.05658 -0.002640 log_tt_b_sig 0.11713 -0.170071 tc_a -0.18343 -0.267890 tc_b 0.12909 -0.303131 hw_a -0.17761 -0.413097 hw_b 0.23024 0.401830 ch_a -0.06656 -0.311757 ch_b -0.33589 0.207405 delta_a -0.13160 -0.034856 gamma_commute_a 1.00000 -0.074172 gamma_car_av_a -0.07417 1.000000 Settings and functions used in model definition: apollo_control -------------- Value modelName "LC_MMNL" modelDescr "Latent class with continuous random parameters on Swiss route choice data" indivID "ID" nCores "4" outputDirectory "output/" mixing "TRUE" debug "FALSE" workInLogs "FALSE" seed "13" HB "FALSE" noValidation "FALSE" noDiagnostics "FALSE" calculateLLC "TRUE" analyticHessian "FALSE" dropLoopExpansion "FALSE" dropRedefCheck "FALSE" panelData "TRUE" analyticGrad "TRUE" analyticGrad_manualSet "FALSE" overridePanel "FALSE" preventOverridePanel "FALSE" noModification "FALSE" Hessian routines attempted -------------------------- numerical jacobian of LL analytical gradient apollo_randCoeff ------------------ function (apollo_beta, apollo_inputs) { randcoeff = list() randcoeff[["tt_a"]] = -exp(log_tt_a_mu + log_tt_a_sig * draws_tt) randcoeff[["tt_b"]] = -exp(log_tt_b_mu + log_tt_b_sig * draws_tt) return(randcoeff) } apollo_lcPars --------------- function (apollo_beta, apollo_inputs) { lcpars = list() lcpars[["tt"]] = list(tt_a, tt_b) lcpars[["tc"]] = list(tc_a, tc_b) lcpars[["hw"]] = list(hw_a, hw_b) lcpars[["ch"]] = list(ch_a, ch_b) V = list() V[["class_a"]] = delta_a + gamma_commute_a * commute + gamma_car_av_a * car_availability V[["class_b"]] = delta_b + gamma_commute_b * commute + gamma_car_av_b * car_availability classAlloc_settings = list(classes = c(class_a = 1, class_b = 2), utilities = V) lcpars[["pi_values"]] = apollo_classAlloc(classAlloc_settings) return(lcpars) } apollo_probabilities ---------------------- function (apollo_beta, apollo_inputs, functionality = "estimate") { apollo_attach(apollo_beta, apollo_inputs) on.exit(apollo_detach(apollo_beta, apollo_inputs)) P = list() mnl_settings = list(alternatives = c(alt1 = 1, alt2 = 2), avail = list(alt1 = 1, alt2 = 1), choiceVar = choice) for (s in 1:2) { V = list() V[["alt1"]] = asc1 + tc[[s]] * tc1 + tt[[s]] * tt1 + hw[[s]] * hw1 + ch[[s]] * ch1 V[["alt2"]] = asc2 + tc[[s]] * tc2 + tt[[s]] * tt2 + hw[[s]] * hw2 + ch[[s]] * ch2 mnl_settings$utilities = V P[[paste0("Class_", s)]] = apollo_mnl(mnl_settings, functionality) P[[paste0("Class_", s)]] = apollo_panelProd(P[[paste0("Class_", s)]], apollo_inputs, functionality) P[[paste0("Class_", s)]] = apollo_avgInterDraws(P[[paste0("Class_", s)]], apollo_inputs, functionality) } lc_settings = list(inClassProb = P, classProb = pi_values) P[["model"]] = apollo_lc(lc_settings, apollo_inputs, functionality) P = apollo_prepareProb(P, apollo_inputs, functionality) return(P) }